FAQ
We’ve compiled a list of our most frequently asked questions regarding what The Bonhoeffer Project is all about. Please note, this is not an exhaustive list. If you still have questions, please send us an email (info@thebonhoefferproject.com) and we’ll be happy to answer.
-
The Grand Experiment at Finkenwalde.
In 1935, a young German pastor named Dietrich Bonhoeffer watched the church around him collapse. Not from persecution—from compromise. The German church had made peace with the rising Nazi regime, blending Christian language with political ideology until Jesus became unrecognizable.
Bonhoeffer refused.
He launched what he called his "Grand Experiment"—an illegal underground seminary at Finkenwalde where he gathered young pastors and did something radical: he trained them to be disciple-makers by actually following Jesus together. They studied Scripture. They prayed. They rediscovered Jesus. They shared life as a community of disciples.
He saw it clearly: we'd built a religion that uses Jesus to get people into heaven but leaves out his most central call—"Come, follow me." Grace without discipleship. Forgiveness without transformation. Christianity without Christ. Amidst our theological systems and salvation explanations, we'd lost Jesus himself.
He wrote: "Christianity without discipleship is always Christianity without Christ."
The Gestapo shut down Finkenwalde in 1937. Bonhoeffer was executed in April 1945, just weeks before the war ended—hanged for his resistance to evil.
But his Grand Experiment proved something: When pastors and ministry leaders gather to recenter on Jesus—his message, his mission, his model—they can lead movements that push back darkness and transform the world.
We're here to carry on this Grand Experiment.
To be clear: this cohort is not a study of Bonhoeffer's life or theology. Our focus is Jesus and his mission to make disciples. We bear Bonhoeffer's name because we're carrying on what he started at Finkenwalde—gathering pastors and ministry leaders in community to become disciple-making leaders for Jesus.
The Western church faces its own crisis today. We've unknowingly offered people a Christianity that says you can be a Christian without following Christ. Forty million American churchgoers have walked away in the last 25 years—not because they rejected Jesus, but because we’ve unknowingly given them religion instead of him.
The Bonhoeffer Project gathers small cohorts of pastors and ministry leaders for a year to do what Bonhoeffer did: rediscover Jesus together. Not in a classroom. In community. Learning to be disciple-making leaders by being disciples together.
We bear Bonhoeffer's name because his conviction is our conviction: The church's renewal won't come from that better program or product. It will come from pastors and leaders who dare to follow Jesus themselves—and then lead others to do the same.
The Grand Experiment continues. Will you join in?
-
We gather pastors and ministry leaders into year-long cohorts—small communities around the world of 5-12 leaders who spend a year rediscovering Jesus together: his gospel, his mission, and his model of making disciples.
This isn't a conference or a course. It's an intentional leadership community where you'll study Scripture, pray, wrestle with hard questions, rebuild a clear understanding of your why, and craft a customized disciple-making plan for your context.
Over 10 monthly gatherings, you'll:
Reclaim the Kingdom Gospel that naturally leads to discipleship (not just conversion)
Learn from Jesus' model—how he actually made disciples and what that means for your leadership
Build a customized plan that fits your context's size, culture, and resources
Join a growing network of 1,000+ alumni committed to Jesus-centered disciple-making
You'll leave with three things: theological and missional clarity, a practical plan, and a community of leaders who share your conviction that the church's renewal comes from following Jesus—and leading others to do the same.
The Bonhoeffer Project isn't building an institution. We're catalyzing a movement—a network of leaders who've rediscovered Jesus and His way, and are committed to his mission of making disciples who make disciples.
World revolution through local movements of disciple-making. That's what we're after. And it starts with leaders like you.
*For more information, check out our cohorts page.
-
The Cohort: $1,500 per participant
Covers all 10 sessions, curriculum materials, access to the alumni network, etc.
That’s $150 per month for a gathering, focused transformation, and personal discipleship coaching.
After the Cohort:
There are no ongoing membership fees, no required conferences, no hidden costs.
You'll walk away with a customized disciple-making plan for your context.
The cohort gives you theological clarity and space to develop a strategic framework. What you build for your context is entirely up to you.
We believe in financial transparency because pastors deserve to budget wisely. If the $1,500 cohort fee is a barrier, scholarships may be available.
*If you would like to help make scholarships available for other pastors and ministry leaders around the globe, visit our donate page.
-
No. And unfortunately, anyone who promises you one is lying.
There are no silver bullets in discipleship—no "one size fits all" program that will magically transform your church, organization, or neighborhood. We've been there. We've tried that. We've been those well-meaning leaders who buy the latest curriculum or programs, launch it with hope, and watch it fizzle because it wasn't built for our context. It came from a different context and a different philosophy of ministry. No matter how good, it will never quite…fit.
Here's the truth: Discipleship to Jesus isn't a product you purchase. It's a culture you cultivate. And culture requires integration to your ‘why’ and customized, contextualized plans.
That's why The Bonhoeffer Project doesn't hand you a pre-packaged program. We give you something better: a 10-month process where you'll develop your own plan.
You'll:
Grow in your theology of discipleship—understanding the Kingdom Gospel that naturally leads to disciples
Learn from Jesus' model—studying how he actually made disciples, not how we wish he did
Craft a customized plan built specifically for your context—your people, your culture, your local values, your resources
Sharpen it in community—your cohort leader and fellow participants will challenge, refine, and strengthen your plan
Battle-test it—you'll implement as you go, learning what works and what doesn't in real time
The result? A disciple-making plan that's biblically grounded, contextually relevant, and actually yours—not something copied from a megachurch playbook, an emerging influencer’s kit, or a model from three decades ago.
Silver bullets don't exist. But disciple-making leaders who know their context and follow Jesus' model? They change everything.
-
No—though lead pastors make up a significant portion of our cohorts.
Who participates:
Lead/Senior Pastors (the largest group)
Executive/Teaching Pastors
Discipleship/Formation Pastors
Church Planters
Associate Pastors and Ministry Directors
Non-profit and Parachurch Leaders who want to build disciple-making into their organizational DNA
Marketplace Leaders seeking to catalyze disciple-making movements in their workplaces or neighborhoods
Denominational Leaders and Church Network Directors
Emerging Leaders being developed for future leadership
The key qualifier isn't your title—it's your conviction and context.
If you want to see a disciple-making movement for Jesus take hold in your sphere of influence—whether that's a church, a non-profit, a neighborhood, a workplace, or a network—this cohort is for you.
The cohort requires you to craft and implement a disciple-making plan specific to your context. That means you need:
Influence or leadership responsibility in your setting
The ability to act on what you learn (not just observe)
A genuine desire to see people become disciples of Jesus who make disciples
Can I just come and learn without a context?
The cohort is designed for those who are leading, shepherding, or shaping culture in a ministry, organization, or missional context. This can be your neighborhood or place of work, but you WILL need a context to do disciple-making for this cohort to be beneficial.
Team Participation:
Some churches or organizations send multiple leaders through together (e.g., lead pastor + discipleship director, or executive director + program lead). This can create powerful shared vision and language across your team. Each person pays separately, but discounts are available in this case.
Bottom line: If you're responsible for leading or shaping disciple-making in any context—church, parachurch, marketplace, neighborhood—and you're ready to build a movement, you should apply for a Bonhoeffer Project cohort.
The question isn't whether your title qualifies you. The question is: Are you ready to lead a disciple-making movement for Jesus in your world?
Got More Questions?
Below are some more questions. But if you’ve gotten this far, why don’t you consider applying for a cohort?
-
Because what you're currently doing isn't sustainable—and you know it.
Here's the truth: Most pastors are exhausted because they're running programs that don't produce disciples. You're working harder to keep people engaged in a system that's not designed for transformation. The American church has lost 40 million people in the last 25 years—not because they rejected Jesus, but because we gave them Christianity without discipleship.
This cohort isn't adding one more program to your plate. It's helping you redesign the plate itself.
The time commitment is real: 10 monthly gatherings (2-3 hours each) plus 4-6 hours of reading and homework monthly. That's roughly 6-9 hours per month. But here's what shifts: You're not planning out what you’ll do in addition to your work—you're rethinking what you are meant to do as your work. The cohort becomes your strategic planning, your theological development, your peer supervision, and your reminder of ‘the why’ in one integrated space.
Alumni consistently report that the year feels less like "one more thing" and more like finally getting clarity on the one thing that matters. As Bill Hull says: "The gospel you preach determines the disciples you make." Getting that upstream issue right changes everything downstream.
The tough truth is: If you're too busy to step back and examine whether your ministry is actually making disciples, you're likely too busy to fulfill the Great Commission.
-
Absolutely. In fact, churches with existing pathways often get more from the cohort, not less.
Here's why:
You'll gain theological depth. Having a program or pathway is different from having clear theological conviction about why discipleship is the non-negotiable center of the gospel. Many churches have pathways that inadvertently communicate discipleship is optional for "serious Christians." The cohort helps you examine and refine the theology underneath your current practice.
You'll evaluate what's actually working. The cohort gives you space to honestly assess: Is your current pathway producing multiplying disciples, or just informed consumers? Is it actually a bridge to deeper church life, or a cul-de-sac? Sometimes the answer is "this part is working great—give it more fuel." Sometimes it's "we need to tweak this." Sometimes it’s “this is trash and we need something different.” Either way, you'll know.
You'll learn from Jesus' model. Session 7 focuses specifically on how Jesus made disciples—his ways and means. Even if your pathway is solid, learning directly from Jesus' methodology will sharpen your leadership and plan. Nothing leaves that session unchanged.
You'll customize it further. During Sessions 4-6, participants work on customizing their approach. If you already have something, you'll spend that time refining it with input from cohort peers and facilitators.
Bottom line: The cohort isn't about adopting some program we’re selling. It's about becoming a disciple-making leader who can steward whatever pathway God has given you with greater clarity and effectiveness.
Some of our most impactful alumni came in with strong existing pathways and left as even sharper disciple-making leaders.
-
Great question. The market is crowded with discipleship frameworks—3DM, Exponential, Alpha, Rooted, and dozens of others. Here's what makes TBP distinct:
We Start Upstream: The Gospel Itself
Most discipleship programs assume you've got the gospel right and just need better methods. We don't. We start by examining whether the gospel you're preaching naturally leads to following Jesus the King. Sessions 1-2 focus entirely on gospel clarity—because as Bill Hull says, "The gospel you preach determines the disciples you make."
If your gospel in entirety is "Jesus died so you can go to heaven when you die," you'll make converts, not disciples. We help you reclaim the biblical Kingdom Gospel that Jesus actually preached.
No Silver Bullets
We're not selling you a packaged program or sending experts to fix your church. We're inviting you into a year-long cohort of 5-10 peers who learn together, pray together, and build together. This is patterned after Bonhoeffer's Finkenwalde experiment—an illegal seminary where leaders rediscovered Jesus: his message, his model, his mission.
You don't hire us. You don’t ‘buy’ anything we’re selling. You join us.
We Prioritize the Pastor's Soul
Session 9 focuses entirely on you—the leader. Your calling, your sustainability, your own discipleship. We don't just ask "What will you do?" We ask "Who are you becoming?" Many cohort participants say this session alone was worth the entire year.
We Customize, Not Franchise
We don't hand you a pre-built program and say "run this." We equip you to build what fits your context. Each participant crafts a disciple-making plan specific to their church or context’s size, culture, and resources. We provide principles, not products.
We're more Movement than Organization
We're decentralized by design. Our goal isn't to build an institution—it's to catalyze a widespread return to Jesus-centered discipleship across denominations, networks, and regions. Jesus’ disciple-making multiplies, we’re after the same goal.
Bottom Line:
Other ‘discipleship’ products and frameworks sell something you have to fit into your context.
The Bonhoeffer Project gives you theological clarity, helps you build customized plan for your context, and offers a community of like-minded leaders—then sends you out to lead a local movement of disciple-making carrying your language, your specific mission to your specific people, drenched in the ways of Jesus.
We're not competing with organizations like Alpha, Rooted, 3DM, Radical Mentoring, etc.. Many TBP churches use them in their pathways. We're after something deeper: helping you become a Jesus-centered, disciple-making pastor who leads a Jesus-centered, disciple-making church.
-
We have two distinct types of cohorts.
TRADITIONAL - The original cohort model where participants gather in person, around a table, on a monthly basis. This experience allows you to learn from each other in real time and make lasting connections.
HYBRID - Having participants around the world requires a more flexible model. Some gathering may be in person and some on Zoom. Or, participants will meet in person and some will join online via Zoom for monthly gatherings.
VIRTUAL - All participants will meet online via Zoom for each monthly gathering.
-
No—though lead pastors make up a significant portion of our cohorts.
Who participates:
Lead/Senior Pastors (the largest group)
Executive/Teaching Pastors
Discipleship/Formation Pastors
Church Planters
Associate Pastors and Ministry Directors
Non-profit and Parachurch Leaders who want to build disciple-making into their organizational DNA
Marketplace Leaders seeking to catalyze disciple-making movements in their workplaces or neighborhoods
Denominational Leaders and Church Network Directors
Emerging Leaders being developed for future leadership
The key qualifier isn't your title—it's your conviction and context.
If you want to see a disciple-making movement for Jesus take hold in your sphere of influence—whether that's a church, a non-profit, a neighborhood, a workplace, or a network—this cohort is for you.
The cohort requires you to craft and implement a disciple-making plan specific to your context. That means you need:
Influence or leadership responsibility in your setting
The ability to act on what you learn (not just observe)
A genuine desire to see people become disciples of Jesus who make disciples
Can I just come and learn without a context?
The cohort is designed for those who are leading, shepherding, or shaping culture in a ministry, organization, or missional context. This can be your neighborhood or place of work, but you WILL need a context to do disciple-making for this cohort to be beneficial.
Team Participation:
Some churches or organizations send multiple leaders through together (e.g., lead pastor + discipleship director, or executive director + program lead). This can create powerful shared vision and language across your team. Each person pays separately, but discounts are available in this case.
Bottom line: If you're responsible for leading or shaping disciple-making in any context—church, parachurch, marketplace, neighborhood—and you're ready to build a movement, you should apply for a Bonhoeffer Project cohort.
The question isn't whether your title qualifies you. The question is: Are you ready to lead a disciple-making movement for Jesus in your world?
-
We've trained 1,000+ pastors and ministry leaders across 150+ cohorts since 2015, representing:
Church Sizes:
Church plants (under 50)
Small churches (50-150)
Mid-sized churches (150-500)
Large churches (500+)
Contexts:
Urban, suburban, and rural
Denominational (Baptist, Free Methodist, Brethren, Presbyterian, non-denominational, Vineyard, Anglican, and others)
Revitalization and established healthy churches
Multi-site and single-campus
Churches, non-profits, neighborhood movements, etc.
What we hear consistently:
"This gave us a north star when everything else felt like competing priorities"
"Our staff finally aligned around a common vision"
"We stopped adding programs and started making disciples"
Want to hear from our alumni? Visit our testimonials page to hear from those who have gone through our cohort.